Markets

Can Kalshi persuade prediction traders to keep stocks on its platform?

Kalshi reportedly plans to offer stock and ETF trading through a broker. The bigger test is whether users fund those accounts and leave securities there.

Open blue records drawer holding blank cream cards beside a translucent perforated ticket.
AI-generated editorial illustration created with Codex.
In this article

Once an event contract settles, the trader can put the proceeds toward another contract or take the money out. A stock account would give Kalshi a chance to build a relationship that lasts between trades. That requires a different decision from the customer. Buying a stock on impulse takes one order. Moving a portion of an existing portfolio means choosing where to keep it.

The Wall Street Journal reported that Kalshi bought broker-dealer FB Securities in July and planned to introduce stock trading. CBS News separately reported plans for both stocks and exchange-traded funds, citing a person familiar with the matter. FINRA’s BrokerCheck lists FB Securities as registered with the SEC and FINRA since December 2025. It lists Kalshi as an indirect owner with a stake of at least 75% and dates the establishment of that ownership relationship to October 2026. The July transaction date comes from reporting. The October entry describes the ownership relationship recorded by FINRA. A customer launch date would require separate confirmation. The Wall Street Journal · CBS News · FINRA BrokerCheck

Who would hold a customer’s shares

Opening a securities account through an app can involve two firms. An introducing broker can handle the relationship with the customer and accept orders. A carrying firm can receive and hold the cash and securities and support settlement. In a fully disclosed arrangement, FINRA’s rules require the agreement to allocate responsibilities such as opening accounts, accepting orders and sending confirmations. The carrying firm is responsible for safeguarding customer assets and for account statements, even where it authorizes the introducing firm to handle statements on its behalf with FINRA approval. Customers must receive written notice of how the responsibilities are divided when the account is opened. FINRA Rule 4311

BrokerCheck names Apex Clearing and Interactive Brokers in separate fully disclosed clearing arrangements at FB Securities. Those entries describe the broker’s arrangements. The brokerage disclosures at launch would establish which firm does what for a Kalshi customer. That distinction matters if a customer wants to transfer a holding, locate a statement or resolve a discrepancy in a dividend payment. FB Securities firm report · SEC investor bulletin on holding securities

Two positions linked to the same stock

A person who buys a share held in street name is its beneficial owner. An intermediary is the registered holder and the brokerage records the customer’s interest. Dividends, when paid, are credited through that chain, and it supplies proxy materials for shareholder votes. A fully paid position can remain in a securities account without the customer posting collateral against ordinary price moves. SEC investor bulletin on holding securities

KalshiEX’s November 17 filing with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission covered a different instrument. The exchange submitted a self-certification for 36 additional perpetual futures tied to individual stocks or American depositary receipts. Those contracts have no fixed expiry, settle in cash and use a daily funding mechanism that can transfer money between long and short positions. Holding the contract gives the trader price exposure. The funding mechanism can reflect an ordinary dividend without giving the trader a shareholder vote. The rules require margin while a position is open, and a shortfall can lead to liquidation. For someone who intends to keep exposure for several months, those ongoing cash flows and collateral needs can matter as much as the share-price move. KalshiEX product certification

The balances after the first trade

Kalshi could make the first stock purchase convenient for someone already using the app. It is harder to persuade that customer to move savings or a portfolio from another broker. A customer could place a few equity orders on Kalshi and continue to hold most assets elsewhere. That could still generate useful trading activity. It would give the brokerage a smaller share of the customer’s finances and leave activity more dependent on repeat orders.

Even a rising securities balance would need interpretation. Robinhood’s third-quarter filing shows one way to do that. It identifies $15.7 billion of company-defined net deposits and $11.5 billion of net market gains as separate contributors to growth in total platform assets. Its net-deposit measure includes items such as dividends and incentives as well as cash deposits and asset transfers, so it is broader than a tally of portfolios that customers brought from another broker. Growth in asset prices can flatter a balance measure even if few customers move new money. Robinhood’s third-quarter Form 10-Q

The account disclosures would provide the first concrete evidence of the offer. Transfer terms would help clarify whether customers can bring existing positions with them and what it would cost to move them again. They would show which firms are responsible for carrying accounts and what customers can do with their holdings. A business that can attract lasting assets would show up later in funded accounts, net transfers from outside and balances still held by the same customers after the first trade. That is a more demanding test than persuading someone who already follows an event to try one more trade.

Sources

Information and estimates for educational purposes. They do not constitute personal financial advice. About & methodology →

Continue reading